Book Review: The Good Earth; Pearl S. Buck
Posted in books with tags book review, pearl s. buck, pulitzer prize, china, classic novels, the good earth on February 3, 2008 by traci
Title: The Good Earth
Author: Pearl S. Buck
Type: Fiction
Genre: Historical Fiction
Number of pages: 357
Link: @ BN.com
Rating: 44/50 - 88% - B.
Though more than sixty years have passed since this remarkable novel won the Pulitzer Prize, it has retained its popularity and become one of the great modern classics. “I can only write what I know, and I know nothing but China, having always lived there,” wrote Pearl Buck. In The Good Earth she presents a graphic view of China when the last emperor reigned and the vast political and social upheavals of the twenty century were but distant rumblings for the ordinary people. This moving, classic story of the honest farmer Wang Lung and his selfless wife O-lan is must reading for those who would fully appreciate the sweeping changes that have occurred in the lives of the Chinese people during this century.
Plot:
The novel begins on Wang Lung’s wedding day and follows through his wedding and the birth of his first four children, a move to the south to work in a city, and back again to the farm. In the beginning he is poor, and in the end, he is rich.
I have never been outside of the US but as I read this novel, I had no problem picturing rural, pre-revolutionary China. I have to admit I was a little nervous-the plotline seemed a little dull from reading the back of the book, and people even said to me, “that sounds so boring!”
And I think it had potential to be. If I’m completely honest, I know the plotline was simplistic and there wasn’t really any big surprise. It wasn’t one of those books where I laughed and cried with the characters. But I did keep continually turning pages to see what happened. I rooted for Wang Lung in the beginning, and later I wanted to punch him for his treatment of O-lan. And I hated his first two sons-what jerks they were!
The plotline of this novel taught me a lot. I didn’t really know much of anything about pre-revolutionary China before reading this, but I think I could probably be pressed to say something about it now, if I had to. I loved the way the characters’ voices really told the story: there was a scene in the city where the missionaries were attempting to educate the Chinese about Christianity, and it could have been handled completely differently and not made the impact it did. The author could have said, “Wang Lung looked at the picture of Christ…” but instead, we’re told that he sees a bunch of men yelling about a white man bleeding and crucified, Wang Lung makes a mention of how he must’ve done something really bad to deserve such a humiliating death, and then takes the paper home to O-lan so she can use it to make shoes. Humbling? You bet.
Total points: 18/20.
Characters:
I have to say, honestly, that I felt something strong for all of the characters. I loved Wang Lung at first, as he was preparing for his wedding day, worried about how his new wife would see him and all the things he was going to do right. And by the end, I didn’t like him as much. He mistreated her, threw her aside for his second wife. The scene with the pearls really solidified my dislike of him.
I didn’t like O-lan too much at first, or her father-in-law, but by the end of the novel I think they were probably my two favorite characters. O-lan was unselfish and strong, giving birth by herself and working the fields with Wang Lung even though she didn’t have to. She did everything she could to make ends meet and went above and beyond to care for her husband, her father-in-law, and her children, and she was completely unappreciated for it. The father-in-law, while he wasn’t a main character or even given a name, was kind of the cornerstone for the whole novel, I think. He represented the past, in a way-what Wang Lung came from (and eventually forgot). I felt so proud when he refused to beg in the streets of the city-like maybe other people should take a page from his book once in a while.
Wang Lung’s children, on the other hand, were not as great. His first two sons were spoiled and hateful and I didn’t like them at all. The first daughter, his fool, was probably the only one out of the whole bunch that I really liked, and that was only because she managed to win her father over without even knowing she did it. The twins were okay, too; I felt terrible for the girl twin because she wasn’t liked very much and the fact that she was sent away and it was only casually mentioned really sucked. I felt bad for her twin brother, but only because he overshadowed by his two brat brothers.
Total Points: 8/10.
Readability:
This was a quick and easy read, especially for a novel written in that time period. I was surprised to find it that easy to get through. There weren’t any glaring grammar or spelling errors, but it was written in a flowing, choppy sort of style that was more suited to a journal entry than a novel. But it didn’t detract from the book in any way; I saw it as more of Wang Lung’s story from his own eyes than I would have if there had been a lot of big words and grammar.
And for being about China, there was remarkably little Chinese in it; everything was done in an understandable style and I still had no problem pretending I was listening to them ramble on in Chinese.
Total Points: 10/10.
Re-readability:
I would love to reread this book! Not immediately, unfortunately, since I don’t have time for that. But it is definitely something I’ll keep around, because one day I will definitely pull it off of the bookshelf and read it again.
Total Points: 4/5.
Anything Else:
–Would I recommend this book to a friend?: Yes! It entertains and teaches a valuable lesson at the same time.
–Do I want to see a sequel or a series from this book? Am I going to look for more material by this author?: I read on Wikipedia that this was book one of a trilogy, and I might go look for those. I think I liked the ending of this one, though, but I’m not going to say no to the other two if I find them. Also, the author wrote East Wind: West Wind, which I think sounds a lot more interesting than the books following this one.
–Would I like to see fan media for this novel?: I don’t think this is really a novel where fan media is exactly appropriate, but I wouldn’t say no to it at all.
–Is it worth paying the cover price? (on the back of the book): ($14 - US) For the first time ever, I’m going to say yes.
–Other impressions/things to note: Unfortunately, I think a lot of people have to read this for class and I know that ruins it. But since I just read it for pleasure and didn’t have to do an assigned project on it or anything like that, I know that changes my perception a little.
Total Points: 4/5.



